Entertainment Review Of The Week: The Children's Hour
I was really dreading reviewing this film. This film consisted my two favorite actors, Audrey Hepburn and James Garner, and their roles in the film were just mind boggling, they were so good, but it's also the most controversial film I have ever seen. Before I say anything else, I will say, the best acting I have seen in a very long time in a film and excellent cinemotography.
So begins the issue of The Children's Hour.
Two teachers, Karen (Hepburn) and Martha (McLaine), have been best friends for several years and they decided to open a boarding school for girls. They have been struggling a bit due to financial problems, so this becomes the reason why Karen holds off on her engagment to the local doctor, Joe (Garner). Finally Karen agrees to marry Joe, but Martha is not too happy about this. A student, Mary Tilford, who is a trouble maker and a compulsive liar wil do anything to make Karen and Martha look bad. So, Mary spreads a nasty rumor that Karen and Martha are actually lesbians. Mary tells her grandmother who tells every parent who has their girls in the school. Eventually, every girl is taken out of the school, far away from the "unnatural" sights. Making this a tragedy, Karen and Martha suffer through dilemmas both internally and externally. After a long and tiring time, they go through the court, and they became nationally known as the lesbian teachers. Men come by in trucks and smash their windows or drop off random things just to get a "sight." A few strings begin to untie, and Mary, the student who spread the rumor, admits to lying. The grandmother has a large apology to the two teachers. This isn't enough though because Martha eventually begins to believe the rumor herself, and admits her love for Karen. Karen is appalled by this, and tries to knock some sense into her. Karen goes outside to take a walk, but when she comes back in, she finds Martha hanging from her bedroom ceiling.
So. This film/play has a lot good points. It proves how much it is important not to lie because things like this are born. In this sense, it reminds me a bit of Atonement, which stars Keira Knightley (why I put up the newer movie poster there) because of one child's lie, the whole world turns upside down. Another is the more you hear something, the more you think about it. The mre you think about it, the more you begin to believe it. Martha suffered from this, as well as Joe, Karen's fiance. They heard them being accused so much that eventually, they began to believe it themselves.
Bad points. I believe the film/play could have had a different scenario. I was shocked to even see such a controvserial issue in a 1960's movie., especially when it received 5 nominations at the Oscars. Typically, you didn't see this kind of stuff until the early 1990's, but I don't believe it promotes or demotes gays in any which way. I believe it just proved that lying isn't the way to get out of things. I won't express real opinions about it, but I'll say this much: I was highly uncomfortable watching this film. I will not be rating it, but I wanted to let people know ahead of time what it is about.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0054743/